Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts

Saturday, January 7, 2012

Elk Cliff Bank

Some of you know I played law professor this Fall, teaching a "practicum" course at Washington & Lee University School of Law. Under a new program, students in their final year at this school take only clinical and practicum courses intended to acclimate them to next year's "real life." (Occasionally a student might take a "doctrinal" course if he or she has a prospective employer who requires a particular course not yet taken.)

Actually I didn't play law professor; I stepped back in time and re-played "General Counsel." I was the boss of the Office of General Counsel, Elk Cliff Bank. The students were attorneys in the Office of General Counsel and employees of the bank.

"What's Elk Cliff Bank?" asks Virginia.

Colonel Francis Anderson founded Elk Cliff Bank in 1832. The bank was a state-chartered “wildcat” bank. A wildcat bank issued its own money. That money was only recognized and honored by Elk Cliff Bank, so you might imagine how much or little comfort the bank's customers felt back then.

The bank was headquartered in the plantation house of Elk Cliff Farm, which had a safe room in its basement. Folks would stop by to make appointments, then return to meet with the Colonel. So the bank has a long history of personalized service.

Beginning in 1863 and 1864, when the National Bank Acts were enacted and national currency arrived, the bank made a point of looking forward. Unlike many family banks, Elk Cliff was not afraid to hire qualified, experienced “outsiders” who favored innovation. That tradition continues today.

Our big job was to implement the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. Our second class began in the Fall of 2008, then we gradually stepped into 2011.

Sunday, December 4, 2011

The Truth Makes Free -- Not Today?

We live in a time of premature verdicts delivered by sponsored sound bites. Dodd-Frank is a failure, pundits cry, with burgeoning regulations driving small banks out of business, making “too big to fail” as certain as death.

To the contrary, the Secretary of the U.S. Treasury Department touts Dodd-Frank as the builder of a pro-growth, pro-investment financial system. Deputy Assistant Secretary Wolin attempts to dispel the “myth” that Dodd-Frank hurts small banks by saying that it helps to level the playing field between large banks and small ones and holds big banks to much stiffer standards than small ones.

So what’s the truth? Will Dodd-Frank spell the death knell for community banks? Is Dodd-Frank swamping banks with regulations, creating job security for compliance officers and attorneys? According to the General Accounting Office in November 2011, “little is known about the actual impact of the final Dodd-Frank rules, given the short amount of time the rules have been in effect.”

Several major criticisms of Dodd-Frank ring true. First, Dodd-Frank did not reinstate Glass-Steagall, the depression era legislation that separated commercial from investment banks, repealed during the Clinton presidency. Second, Dodd-Frank does not explicitly attack the credit default swap exposure that brought down AIG and now poses unclear risk regarding U.S. bank exposure to European sovereign debt.

Most important, if one were to assume that the Dodd-Frank provisions were designed to prevent another financial crisis on the order of the 2008 debacle, a year and a half has passed and most of the legislation remains unimplemented.

Well, say the doubters, banks still aren’t lending, sitting on their cash, all because of Dodd-Frank. That’s easy to say, but what in Dodd-Frank has caused this? Perhaps the specter of Dodd-Frank regulations (such as proposed ability to repay regulations), not yet adopted. More likely, concern about the loosey-goosey practices that led to the crisis and the resulting closer scrutiny of bank examiners, not Dodd-Frank. Even if Dodd-Frank hadn’t come to be, we’d most likely be working through the subprime fallout and banks would be reluctant to lend.

I’m not about to brag on Dodd-Frank. My biggest beef with the bill is its multitude of provisions that will, if they haven’t already, affect institutions that had nothing to do with the financial crisis Dodd-Frank was enacted to prevent. Most lenders did not make NINJA (no income, no job, and no assets) loans. It isn’t fair to treat them all as if they did. Dodd-Frank should have an exemption for the good guys. How to word the exemption and keep it constitutional is something I don’t know much about.

“When you do, let us know, will you?” says Virginia.

Yeah, sure.

"And, by the way, have you bought a Ninja blender yet?" she tosses in.

What?

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Happy Birthday, Dodd-Frank!

Most of us have awakened in the middle of the night and fretted.  Something about the peace and quiet of a dark space often invites focus on something, anything, that suddenly takes on incredible importance.  Next time this happens I think I'll turn on a light, in the hope that seeing other things will turn my thoughts to more realistic matters.

I used to wish that aging would turn me into the kind of wise man people liked to visit.  Phooey.  What a self-centered thought, like the patient who wants everyone to know what he's going through!  I have a feeling wise men have other things to do than hope people want to visit them to learn their secrets.

"Where are you heading with this?" says Virginia.

All right.  You probably don't care one bit that tomorrow, July 21, 2011, is the first anniversary of the enactment of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, a/k/a the financial reform bill or the banking bill.  I, on the other hand, who has been immersed in it day in, day out for the entire year, see the day almost as light at the end of a tunnel, albeit a temporary end.

But yes, I get it.  It means nothing to most people.  It's time to pull weeds in the greenhouse.

Friday, July 1, 2011

One-Third, not One-Twelfth

Someone stuck a summons on our front door a couple weeks ago, for me, to join a panel of peers at the courthouse.  Karen's been wondering why I haven't blogged about this, since I returned to Elk Cliff at 7:30 Wednesday evening.  She could tell right away my day hadn't been pleasant.

The prosecutor had finished his rebuttal about 3:30 and a couple hours later I was afraid the others, anxious to go home, one of them to work, would be throwing darts at me at midnight.  By the time I left the parking garage at seven, I was very grateful for the three jurors who had come to the same conclusion as I.  Hopelessly deadlocked, the judge called us "hung" and declared a mistrial.

Two days later, I'm confident four of us arrived at the "right" answer, although I'm sure some of the others think we wasted their and the government's time.  In fact, near the end, the foreman gave a little speech about how a hung jury would disappoint him, that it would mean our system of justice had failed.  I couldn't let that one go and added my own speech that, no, the system had worked just fine.  If the prosecution wanted to try again, and perhaps do a better job, it could do so and might learn from it, or it might decide the matter wasn't worth another twenty or more person-days of effort and learn from that.  Another fellow pointed out that one reason we require a unanimous verdict is to help prevent like-minded people from railroading a conviction or acquittal.

"Hmm," says Virginia. "I bet you voted not guilty."

Now why would she think that?  Was it something I said, the tilt of my head, a glint in my eyes?  Let me just say, one of the attorneys might regret not kicking me off the jury.  I would have bet I'd be one of the first disqualified.  If there's a next time, I'll probably disqualify myself if given the chance (as we were this time).

Words.  Recently I observed that the Federal Reserve Board writes regulations that contain more than 10 times as many words as the underlying statute.  If that's really necessary, it might seem peculiar that criminal statutes, and jury instructions, tend to be quite short, leaving lots of gray area -- especially when you consider the drastic penalties they entail.  Please don't blame other members of your jury who read the same words differently.

Monday, May 23, 2011

Just Desserts

We've been at this farming thing for 5 years now, maybe settling in.  Karen mentioned rabbits at dinner tonight.  Bambi (venison) I've gotten used to, and Billy (goat), Donald (duck), Chanticleer (rooster), Tom (turkey), I suppose Roger might as well be next.  I have yet to name a plant.  Maybe I should.

Before that seems very long ago.  Talking to some new friends on Saturday reminded me of 17 years ago and earlier, when I was their age driving to work each day. "You never regretted it, did you?" they asked, referring to dropping out of the corporate rat race.  Yes, no regrets, to quote a tattoo that's seen around these parts.  Maybe I should get one.

I've kept in touch with only one person from those days.  He's the only one I bounce ideas off and the only one I know who reads my books now and then.  No one around here except Karen has any idea what's in them.  What are all those rats up to?  Same old, same old, or have they moved on to new horizons?  Hey, any of you rats raising rabbits?

I understand a former boss has retired, appeared on MSNBC not long ago.  He used to convene all of us every Monday morning at 8 to review our weekly reports.  His language was worse than another former boss sentenced to 7 years in a penitentiary (mail fraud and racketeering; interstate transportation of forged securities) who kicked a hole in his office wall one morning and splintered a fake antique chair by tossing it across the room.  By the way, soon after he got out of prison, he was charged again, with a similar mortgage fraud scheme. He pled guilty and went back to jail.  The judge said during sentencing that his criminal activity could not be stopped "short of isolating him from all contact with humanity, like putting him on a desert island."

"Those were the days," says Virginia.

Monday, February 28, 2011

Rain Out

Today we started putting fence rails on the new garden fence.  By the time we installed 5 rails, the skies had dropped enough moisture to send us inside, me to work on impending deadlines.  So I've used today to scan a couple thousand pages of court decisions. 

The financial crisis has obviously taken its toll on the courts.  A rash of predatory lending suits lists every possible mortgage-related federal statute, and many state laws, as the basis for laundry lists of claims.  Most complaints illustrate a lack of creativity among plaintiffs and their lawyers.  They're generally so similar they're hardly worthwhile reading.  Mostly, I watch for old theories being adopted by additional jurisdictions.  Now and then an interesting theory appears.  None today, although I felt a bit sorry for one bankruptcy judge who came up with a nonsensical holding based on his decision to look up the meaning of "originate" in an Internet dictionary.  Did he really have no idea that the term has a pretty clear meaning in the mortgage business?  No surprise, his holding was overturned.

The more interesting decisions fell outside mortgage lending.  Did you ever get mad when you missed your credit card payment date by one or two days, maybe because the mail was slow?  Say you always paid your balance in full, except for that one time?  Boom!  Not only did you have to pay interest for the one or two days late, plus maybe a late charge, you also had to pay interest on the entire preceding billing cycle?  Good reason to set up electronic bill payment with the credit card issuer.  Well, in this case, the cardholder's husband walked the payment into the nearest PNC Bank branch on the due date, a Saturday.  Too bad, it wasn't the location specified on the credit card statement, so the payment wasn't posted and credited until Monday.  The bank "correctly" imposed a finance charge for the 2 days, plus the 32 days of the previous billing cycle.  Because the husband took the payment to the wrong place, the bank had up to 5 extra days to process the payment.  Ouch!

Target apparently did something stupid.  Wanting to replace its in-store "Guest" credit cards, it reportedly mailed Target VISA cards to existing and former cardholders.  The cardholders had the option of calling a toll-free number to validate the VISA cards or cutting them up and staying with their Target Guest Cards.  I guess no one reminded Target that it's not supposed to send out unsolicited credit cards.  Fun-time for a class action!

Then there's the sleazy car dealer who gets you to sign a retail installment sales contract to buy a used car, setting forth the terms of the deal and providing required Truth-in-Lending disclosures (such as the annual percentage rate and payment schedule).  "What's this," you say, "looks likes this contract isn't firm?" You hold up a "Limited Right to Cancel-Purchase," a/k/a "spot delivery agreement," that gives the dealer the right to change the terms of your agreement if it isn't able to sell your contract to the lender that offers the best terms.  "Don't worry," says the dealer, "it's just a legal form.  We have everyone sign it."  A couple days later, the dealer tells you your contract had some errors, so you need to come in and sign another one.  The old "bait and switch."  Ha-ha.  Fortunately, the dealer didn't have the last laugh.

"I guess we need to be careful what we sign," says Virginia.

Yes, even though the stack of documents is 2 inches high and even though you might eventually win in court.  The new Consumer Financial Protection Bureau set up by the Dodd-Frank financial reform act plans to look at the challenge of voluminous disclosures.  In the meantime, happy reading.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

"Keep $$ Local:" Too Big to Fail -- What We Can Do About It

We -- you and I -- share responsibility for "too big too fail."  You know, the idea that certain large financial institutions are so important to our financial system that the government must not allow them to fail.  I've heard and read a lot of griping about this, but unless we already limit our financial dealings to the smaller firms, we're adding to the problem.

Financial reform, through the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, is supposed to take care of this -- so taxpayer funds aren't used again to bail out the big guys.  Maybe Dodd-Frank will solve the problem, maybe it won't.  We can leave that argument for others to fuss about.  In the meantime, we're not completely powerless.

Since the bailouts, we've watched big institutions swallow more little ones.  We've heard about their big bonuses.  We've seen them mishandle mortgage servicing and foreclosures, by using robosigners and being unable to produce supporting documents (such as the promissory notes signed by borrowers).

Yesterday, JP Morgan Chase Bank apologized to active military service members for not paying attention to provisions of the Service Members Civil Relief Act (SCRA), which requires lenders to lower interest rates to 6% and refrain from foreclosing (after becoming aware that customers are on active duty).  This isn't rocket science.  Banks have no excuse for not understanding the SCRA and other laws.  They've been bombarded with articles, book updates, and agency issuances on these topics.

We can complain all we want about bungling by the big guys, to little avail, or we can do something about "too big to fail."  What institutions handle your financial affairs?  Big ones or smaller, local ones?

If your answer is "big ones," then move your money.  Bring it home to firms you know and trust.  And keep an eye on developments.  If a big firm buys the small one you've been using, move your money again.

"Hey, a grass roots revolution!" says Virginia.  "We have the power.  We can do something."

We certainly can try.  We may be surprised by the products and services available through small institutions.  They've changed over the years, and now offer most if not all of what the big ones offer, at least for people like you and me.  Check out your local banks and credit unions.

"What about mortgage payments?" says Virginia.

Well, you might not be able to do much about them.  If you borrowed from a local firm, it may have sold your mortgage loan to a big firm.  Even if you refinance, that loan might be sold, too, although you could shop around for a firm that says it doesn't plan to sell its loans.  If enough people demanded this, the market would have to change to accommodate it.

We've seen "buy fresh, buy local" take off.  How about "invest local, keep your $$ local?"

-- Get rid of big name credit cards.  Keep $$ Local!
-- Move your checking and savings accounts.  Keep $$ Local!
-- If you must finance a car, home improvement, whatever, do it nearby.  Keep $$ Local!
-- Refinance with a community bank, savings association, or credit union.  Keep $$ Local!
-- Bring your stock and bond investments closer to home.  Keep $$ Local!

Of course, you can write your legislators, too.  But don't forget.  Put your money where your mouth is.

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

The Importance of Context

If you're looking for a job, perhaps the courts could use you. About 15 years ago, my friend, David Stemler, and I wrote a book on the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA). That's the law that requires the "Good Faith Estimate" (GFE) of settlement costs you receive when you apply for a home loan, and the settlement statement (HUD-1 or HUD-1A) when the loan closes. Since the book was published, we've updated it 2 or 3 times per year. Back in the early years, it often was hard to find court decisions that dealt with RESPA -- 50 per year was a hefty number. That's no longer the case. I found nearly 500 cases decided between July 1, 2010 and January 2011.

RESPA imposes many other requirements. For example, it prohibits providers of the services involved in obtaining your loan (appraisals, brokers, lenders, real estate agents, pest inspectors, etc.) from paying money to each other unless services are actually rendered. For example, lenders can get into trouble if they give tickets for sporting events to real estate agents who refer loans. I've sometimes wondered if Congress ought to pass a similar law for health care -- for example, restrictions on drug companies flying physicians to Hawaii for classes on a newly approved pill.

RESPA also requires your mortgage loan servicer to respond in a timely manner to your "Qualified Written Request" for information about how it has applied your loan payments and any other questions relating to the servicing of your loan. To be a "Qualified Written Request," you must include specific information in your request (such as enough information to identify you, your loan and the information you want) and send it to the right address.

Consider this: You get a mortgage loan from a local bank, which chooses to service the loan instead of selling the servicing rights to some other company. A year and a half later, you notice your payments haven't been properly credited to your account, so you send a letter about this. RESPA requires your bank to answer you fairly quickly.

Now consider this: You get a mortgage loan from a local bank, which chooses to sell the servicing rights to another company. A year and a half later, you notice the same problem as in the previous paragraph -- your payments haven't been properly credited -- so you send the company a letter. According to a recent court decision -- wrong, I dare say, -- RESPA would allow that company to ignore your letter.

How did the judge come to this conclusion? He turned to a poorly drafted sentence in Regulation X, which implements RESPA: "[A] written request does not constitute a qualified written request if it is delivered to a servicer more than 1 year after either the date of transfer of servicing or the date that the mortgage servicing loan amount was paid in full, whichever date is applicable." Because the servicing company received your letter more than 1 year after the servicing rights were transferred to it, your letter wasn't a "Qualified Written Request" and, as a result, the servicer didn't have to respond.

"Well, I guess that makes sense," says Virginia, "after reading the sentence the court quotes, but the result doesn't make sense to me, the borrower."

It doesn't to me, either, and my money's on other courts disagreeing with this judge. I'm quite sure HUD intended the sentence to have a limited meaning -- referring only to a servicer that receives a letter after servicing has been transferred to another servicer. Otherwise, the response requirement would disappear for up to 29 years of a typical 30-year mortgage. (And Lenders that want to retain servicing might even transfer servicing for a few months and then get it back, in an attempt to escape the response requirement.)

A look at the RESPA statute suggests the judge is wrong. The statute clearly applies to the letter received more than a year after the servicing transfer. On the other hand, the statute gives HUD the authority to adopt regulations and exemptions, so one could argue that the quoted sentence amounts to an exemption. I imagine HUD, or the new Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, will clear this up before long.

By the way, if you want to send a letter to your lender or servicer, HUD offers a sample letter and guidance at www.hud.gov/offices/hsg/ramh/res/reslettr.cfm.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Judge Me Not

I've been self-employed for 17 years, except for one 18-month diversion prefaced by a wiser brother's "why would you want to do that?"  Januarys tend to welcome me to each new year with a reminder of the benefits, as if I need one, such as -- when the inevitable snow falls or ice gathers, I can admire it through a window or retrieve my cross-country skis from the barn.  In fact, it's a perfectly good excuse to stay inside and get some work done, work I then won't have to do on balmy Spring-like days.

This January has been no exception.  As a result, I've immersed myself in court decisions.  Today I read one that worried me a bit because it contradicted something I've written.  I almost left it dangling, certain to pester me in the middle of the night when a train waked me and sent me to the bathroom.  One of the advantages of advancing age is a tendency not to procrastinate about things like this.

According to the judge, a provision of the financial reform bill (Dodd-Frank Act) relating to the Truth-in-Lending Act did not take effect until January 1, 2011, the first day of "the taxable year" following enactment of Dodd-Frank.  I didn't remember this.  In fact, I remembered using too many words to explain what I thought were possible effective dates, none of which was January 1, 2011.

So I pulled up the Act and searched for the words quoted by the judge as calling for January 1, 2011.  They appeared once in the Act, at its very end, after the last section:  "(b) EFFECTIVE DATE.—The amendments made by this section shall apply to taxable years beginning after the date of the enactment of this Act."

"You're boring your readers," says Virginia.  "Cut to the chase."

All right.  The section referred to has nothing to do with the topic the judge was addressing.  The effective date for that topic lies elsewhere.

"Assuming your search function worked," says Virginia.

Yes, good point, but I'm not going to spend half of tomorrow reading the bill word by word, something I've already done several times.

Monday, December 6, 2010

What the Law and Gardening Have in Common

The last couple days have done a number on the arugula.  I should have covered it with a little hoop house.  Mark it up as another gardening lesson.  I can read all sorts of stuff about gardening, but it doesn't sink in until a live, visual, and tactile memory accompanies my recollection of the written word.  Here's a secret:  don't tell the wilted arugula, but if it had been a thriving colony of buttercrunch lettuce, it would have been hooped or cold-framed.

Every day I wander out to the greenhouse for two reasons.  One, to see what the thermometer says early in the morning.  This morning I tapped it in disbelief.  Sixty degrees (F)?  Two, to see what's happened in the raised bed I planted late last week.  I keep imagining a few little green leaves.  Oh, a third reason lately has been to retrieve the stapler to refasten the yellow plastic fence that keeps getting dislodged by our ambitious winds.  Karen informed me this morning that one whole side had blown off the winter wheat garden around the older greenhouse, the one the chickens love to visit.  A hundred feet away, sheltered by hundred-plus-year-old American boxwoods, my more expansive wheat planting is proving much more successful, knock on wood.

Other than trips to the woodshed and mailbox, that's been about it for outdoor recreation this week.  Resting before a "race" is like trying to resist a fresh batch of chocolate chip cookies. To keep my mind cluttered with other things, I'm wending my way through court decisions and helping Virginia grow up.

Today I came across a robo-signer opinion by Judge Arthur Shack of New York, sort of a hero of mine.  If you've been following the foreclosure crisis, you've probably heard of robo-signers, a vocabulary word invented this year to refer to the people hired by mortgage servicers to sign 750 or more loans' worth of mortgage-related documents per day, certifying their accuracy in 30 seconds (about enough time for me to grab a stack and sign one "J").  Speed-reading is not an employment requirement.  In this case, the judge was very frustrated with Ms. Johnson-Seck, her employer (OneWest), and the handful, maybe more, of firms that supposedly had endowed her with the authority to sign their names.  Embarrassed by nationwide publicity, OneWest asked the court to allow the withdrawal of its request for an order of reference (to allow foreclosure).  Judge Shack granted the request, but went a bit further than OneWest wanted -- dismissing the entire case while allowing renewal of the request for an order of reference within 90 days ONLY IF: (1) Ms. Johnson-Seck explained how she happened to be a "vice president" of 4 or 5 different firms; (2) OneWest provided proof of authority from the original lender to MERS (Mortgage Electronic Registration System, Inc.) to IndyMac to OneWest; and (3) OneWest's attorney provided an affirmation that he had personally reviewed the documents and records and confirmed their factual accuracy and the notarizations on the documents.  I imagine that's a tougher row to hoe than a few miles of winter wheat.

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Getting Away With It

Did you know that corporate fraud often, if not usually, involves employees who: (1) have a need; (2) see an opportunity; and/or (3) feel justified in engaging in the fraud?  Not surprising, is it?  If you come up with an observation like that, you might see your name in lights -- the "James rule" or something like that.  Putting a name on something can help people in the dark fight crime.

For example, you've been working at WalMart for a year, you're still earning the minimum wage, and your rent payment looms large.  One of the guys who often punches in when you do frequently breaks for a cigarette and takes twice as long as you to stock a shelf, yet he's paid the same.  You notice that if you pretended to smoke, you could carry a stack of torn-down cardboard boxes out back with you, stick it on a recycling cart, and dilly-dally a few minutes while sucking on an electric smoke.  You might be able to stash a few CDs, some fishing lures or maybe a watch in that stack of cardboard boxes, then drive around back to retrieve them after you get off work.  Don't forget the surveillance cameras.

Or maybe you've been taking the subway to work while the guy in the next cubicle drives a snazzy new Jaguar.  Besides, your penthouse condo could use a new paint job because your housekeeper, though gorgeous, doesn't clean well.  You happen to work for a firm like Goldman-Sachs and decide to create nothing from nothing -- say, maybe a debit delinquent swipe -- and sell it to clueless investors long enough to collect a few eight-digit bonuses.

"I'll take two," says Virginia.

Right.  Her fingers are crossed.

Monday, October 18, 2010

Cutting Corners

Have you been wondering what the foreclosure fuss is all about?

"A little," says Virginia.  "Fill me in, please."

Two years ago, I reported a series of opinions by Judge Shack, New York, who began to throw foreclosure plaintiffs out of court because they had failed to show their appearance in the chain of title. 

"What's that?" says Virginia.

All right, let's go back to the beginning.  When you take out a home mortgage loan, you sign a stack of paperwork.  Two very important papers to the lender are: (1) a promissory note and (2) a mortgage (a/k/a security instrument, deed to secure debt, security deed, deed of trust).  The promissory note (a/k/a note) is your personal promise to repay the loan.  The mortgage is your pledge of your home to secure your promise to pay; if you don't keep your promise, it gives the lender the right to take your home and sell it to repay what you owe.

When you close your loan and sign the documents, the closing agent (attorney, title company or escrow agent) scurries with your mortgage to the appropriate land records office.  In general, the first to record has priority over later recordings, so your lender wants to be first.

In not so olden times, you paid your lender each month and eventually, after 15-30 years or when you sold your home, you paid off the entire loan and your lender released the mortgage -- at which time you owned your home "free and clear" (if ever so briefly, perhaps). In modern times, the lender wants to recycle its funds and re-lend them, so it sells your loan to someone else.  That helps explain why you make the first few payments to your lender, then for a couple years you pay X and then for several more years you pay Y. 

Also in not so olden times, each time your loan was sold, the buyer recorded an assignment of mortgage in the land records office so everyone knew it now owned your loan.  That cost a few bucks.  In modern times, the lender sold your loan to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac or some other firm that collected gobs of loans and "securitized" them, breaking the various loans into categories (such as prime or high quality, subprime or low quality) and even separating individual loans into pieces (such as the right to receive principal, the right to receive interest, the right to receive late payments, etc.).  In turn, the securitizer sold the various pieces to investors and, to encourage them to buy, included a few warranties and representations in the governing documents.  Rather than record assignments for each transfer of the various interests (and pay the land records office for each one), Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and others in the mortgage industry set up a private company to keep track of who owned what and called the company Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc. or MERS.  Reportedly, MERS hasn't done a stellar job so things have gotten confused.  Besides, some of the land records offices aren't happy about being sidestepped and some of their lawyers (in the form of state attorneys general) are challenging the MERS system.  And other folks messed up outside the MERS system.

If you stop paying your mortgage loan, the current owner or owners won't be happy with you.  Your original lender sold the loan, so it's pretty much out of the picture (although it made some warranties when it sold your loan that could come back to haunt it).  The current owner or owners generally are represented by the servicer to whom you're supposed to send payments, so the servicer or someone it hires eventually will sue you to take possession of your home, relying on the mortgage you signed (it might be able to do this through a nonjudicial process without suing you, but for simplicity's sake we'll limit our discussion to the use of courts).  The challenge for the servicer or the person it hires is to show it has a right to sue you -- by tracing its right back through various documents to the mortgage you signed, that is, a good chain of title.  If MERS or one of the previous owners messed up, that can be tough to do.  Or even if no one messed up, it might be troublesome to gather all the relevant documents and present them to a court in a meaningful way.  As a result, the servicer or its representative might be tempted to skip some of the necessary steps or even forge a document that appears to make some of those steps unnecessary.

That's where we are today -- in one big mess, thanks in part to some of the same folks to whom we generously donated many of our tax dollars a couple years ago.  Oh yeah, they repaid us, hmmm....which has much to do with the big bundle of so-called toxic assets the U.S. Treasury now holds, many of which are gummed up in the foreclosure mess?  Maybe the U.S. Treasury is busy checking out the warranties mentioned above?

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Come On, Arrest That Man!

I've been studying crazy people, ordinary people, people like you and me. Three times a year I sort through a few hundred court decisions that involve banks and choose about seventy to mention in an encyclopedia-like service called the Banking Law Digest.

One of the cases I couldn't discard involved a visually-impaired fellow named John who enjoyed visiting Ginger in her Philadelphia apartment. Ginger described herself as "an expert at providing personal, hands-on service to individual customers in private sessions at a set rate." In more than 34 sessions over 9 months, she was a great help to our anti-hero.

Then tragedy struck. With the help of his mother's better eyes, our friend reviewed his Discover card receipts and statements and discovered that on 11 occasions dear Ginger had overcharged him. He had thought he was paying between $350 and $700 for each therapy session, but she had tricked him into signing 10 receipts for $1,100 and one for $1,600. No problem with the other sessions, conceded John, although the judge footnoted a bit of concern: "The record does not reveal how one would know whether the events of any individual session...were worth $375 or $750. [John] is definite about one thing, though: [he] is not claiming...that [Ginger] breached a contract by failing to perform...services up to snuff...[and he] is not claiming that [her] technique did not justify her price."

No prude and no slouch, and feeling put-upon, John disputed the charges with his credit card company. Ginger produced the signed receipts, along with a copy of the contract John had signed -- for "yoga and pilates services." John sued Discover anyway. Why? Because Discover, he claimed, had violated the Americans With Disabilities Act by failing to consider his blindness when investigating his fraud claim.

Poor blind John. Philadelphia not being Las Vegas, the judge didn't look kindly on his walking into court to enforce a credit card contract he had violated by using his credit card to pay for illegal services. Besides, Discover offered a 24-7 telephone number designed to allow folks with vision impairments to check on their account charges.

"You're kidding me, aren't you?" asks Virginia. "He didn't really sue, did he?"

Twice. Not one to give up, he decided to "seek redress from Ginger directly" and hailed her into the Court of Common Pleas.

Sunday, September 26, 2010

Practice for Fun

People sometimes ask if I still practice law.  Like practicing medicine, it may say something about humility.  If I answer "yes," I'm lying.  If I answer, "no," then it sounds as if I'm bragging -- "nope, finally got it figured out and don't need to 'practice' any more."

Then they ask if I still play piano (or violin).  The older I get, the more I like that question.  As a young person, it sounded child-like and immature.  Think of Picasso admiring the art of children.  I like the idea that musicians play.  What a wonderful profession or avocation!  It's play.  The key is to keep it play.

A local radio station's jazz announcer recently quoted Dr. Lonnie Smith, the Hammond B3 jazz organist, as having said, "It's not important how you play; what's important is how you feel."  I'm sure he didn't mean you shouldn't practice or play.   I doubt he meant you should practice how you feel.  Rather, you should play how you feel and feel when you play. 

"In opera, we got to play and act," says Virginia.  "I tried to keep work to the minimum, and practicing fun.  It became too much of a challenge."

She reminds me of the piano instructor I had in Chapel Hill, who once said, "I envy you.  Whenever you play piano, it's fun.  For me, it's always work."  Sorry, teach.

Thursday, September 23, 2010

Dreams

My grandfather, in his memoir, We Two, Twice Twinned, divided his life into 20-year segments:  student; missionary; seminary president/teacher; and author.  Twenty years doesn't work for me.  After the child/student part, which ran closer to 25, practicing law filled 16-20 depending on how you figure it, and the current phase is now stretching toward 15.  Oops, I can't be that old, can I?

Maybe it's time to interview.  "Tell me about yourself."  Don't you hate that one?  A few minutes have passed since you shook hands and introduced yourself.  You've played the question and answer game about things your social brilliance noticed on the way in, such as soccer pictures or the interviewer's Mickey Mouse tie.  Now it's time to get serious.  Your research has informed you what the business is about, you have an idea what this person does, so now you want to show you're a good fit, probably not as his or her future boss even though, let's face it, that's the right idea.

"Where do you want to be in 5 (or 10) years?"  Ah, show me the door.  Two standard questions in a row are not a good sign, but let's make the best of it.  Maybe the guy/gal completely lacks creativity.  "Doing what I'm doing" is not going to cut it, even if it's true.  It is for me, so it's definitely not time to interview.

I'm not saying that in 5 years I want to be doing exactly what I'm doing now.  That's nonsensical.  Might as well die if that were the case, everything worth doing having been done.  No, I'm saying I think I'd be happy living on this farm, choosing how to use my time, with Karen choosing how to use hers, and Adam somewhere having fun making his choices.  Having a boss other than me isn't in the picture -- unless maybe I'm shooting a movie somewhere, rolling up my sleeves in a House or Senate office building, or, um, playing in the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra. Right.

Dreams.  Do you know people who don't dream?  I do, but I'm not sure I believe them.  They must be aliens.  I enjoy both dreams and nightmares (go ahead and guess which of the above was which).
 
"I have a dream," says Virginia.

"Just one?" I ask.

"More important than all the rest," she says. "Like all of them, they're up to you."

I get it.  Unless I get cracking real soon, I'm going to be either seeking an extension or hauling the old stove up the mountainside.  On the other hand, maybe I'll finish composing that trio for the Arrowheads.

Friday, September 17, 2010

Word Deflation

Some writers have been comparing the length of the health care reform and financial reform bills to the statutes that were passed long ago, such as the Glass-Steagall Act, which were much shorter.  I think they're comparing apples and oranges.  That doesn't mean I favor the trend.

I'll call it word deflation.  It's been going on since the alphabet was created.  Remember the monks who toiled on illuminated manuscripts?  A printed word was worth a fortune in those days.  Only the wealthy owned books.  Then came Gutenberg's printing press.  Years later, when I took my first job after law school, we read typeset galley proofs, word for word.  A year after that, my secretary at First Virginia Banks took dictation with shorthand and used carbon paper and white-out to paint over typing mistakes.  Within 8 years, all of us in the Citi were learning DOS -- before long, WordPerfect, then Word.

With each iteration, a word lost value, to the point where today almost any 10-year old has probably sent more letters (emails) than my grandmother wrote in her entire lifetime.  There's an example.  Thirty years ago, I probably wouldn't have typed "entire lifetime."  The word "lifetime" says the same thing, without risking a mistake and a minute fussing with whiteout.

Yes, I've heard of Twitter.  I applaud Twitter.  It could force us to choose words more carefully. It's an anomaly, or is it?

"Got it," says Virginia.  "What's your point?"

I think it could be interesting to compare today's legislation with yesteryear's.  What do the additional words do?

In a related vein, let's compare regulations written 50 years ago to those written today.  I believe that now there's a tendency to say the same thing several times, in slightly different ways, and to throw in words in an attempt to make perfectly clear what's already clear from the context.  Maybe I'll begin to keep track of the "worst" examples I come across so I can share them with you.

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Religious Freedom

Some folks apparently believe, without saying it, that the Muslim religion attacked the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001, when in fact it was a group of rogue extremists.  Accordingly, no Muslims should be allowed to build a mosque two blocks from Ground Zero.

I ask myself this question: "Would the same brouhaha accompany a proposal to build a Christian church two blocks from the World Trade Center?"  I doubt it.  So what is the connection between the 9/11 massacre and the mosque (which, though pretty much irrelevant, I understand cannot be seen from Ground Zero and which accompanies strip joints and other establishments for which some spiritual enlightenment might be appropriate)? 

Nonsense, fed by the wacky grizzly woman, a former Speaker of the House, and others who should know better.  Let them draw their absurd analogies to countries that weren't built on principles like ours, and may those analogies come back to haunt them in any bids for public office.  As for analogies, it might be appropriate to compare a proposal to build a cathedral near the site where a priest molested young boys or a fundamentalist church near an abortion clinic bombed by a professed Christian.  In this country, I'd like to think we know better than to condemn an entire faith based on the behavior of a few miscreants.

So what if a poll says 61% of Americans oppose the proposed mosque?  That is exactly why the founders of our great country chose to establish the infrastructure they did, with checks and balances and difficult rows to hoe for Constitutional change.  Sometimes we let our emotions carry us away.  Later, when common sense returns, we're glad we had time to reconsider.

I often hear folks gripe about "not being able to pray in public schools."  Yes, we and our children may pray in public schools -- silently, wherever we want.  No, we may not coerce other people into praying in public schools.  Look at it this way.  Some day, when our child has a Muslim teacher, that teacher will not be permitted to ask the student to bow and pray with him or her.

"You sound a little irritated," says Virginia.

Well, it can be frustrating when a gaggle of senators and representatives fail to speak out because they're worried about election results.

Friday, August 20, 2010

Credit Card Questions

Do you ever wonder who makes money if you pay off your no-annual-fee credit card balance in full each month? Do you ever worry that your credit card company (the card issuer) will close your account because you don't pay any finance charges since you never carry a balance from one month to the next? And how can the card issuer afford to give you points for your charges, redeemable for cash? A couple times a year, I go online and either apply my points to help pay the next month's bill or to send me a check.

"Be quick about it," says Virginia.

"All right," say I. "Usually 4 parties besides you are involved in each transaction and each is well-motivated. The network (party 1) charges a fee (interchange fee) that gets paid to the card issuer (party 2) by the retail merchant's bank (party 3), which collects it and a little more from the merchant (party 4) by paying him less than your purchase amount. The network charges fees for its services to the card issuer and the retail merchant's bank. Of course, the merchant charges you more than it paid for whatever you bought."

"You didn't answer the second question," says Virginia.

"Oh yeah," I say. "Don't worry too much. The Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure Act of 2009 included a provision that prohibits a card issuer from terminating your account prior to its expiration date solely because you don't incur a finance charge. Your card issuer might be able to come up with another reason."

"Wow, that's exciting," says Virginia, "and here I was, fretting that I was cheating someone out of something."

"I bet you were. Have a great weekend."

"No cash for me," she says. "I'm using my cards wherever I can."

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Words

The Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure Act of 2009 (that’s right, no commas in there) included a 1,118-word provision on gift certificates, store gift cards and general-use prepaid cards. The section prohibits dormancy fees, inactivity charges and service fees unless:

(1) the consumer hasn’t used the card in the past year;
(2) specified disclosures have been given;
(3) not more than one fee is charged in any given month; and
(4) any additional requirements set by the Federal Reserve Board have been satisfied.

The section also prohibits expiration dates, unless the date is at least 5 years after issuance and the terms of expiration are clearly disclosed.

The Act gave the Fed until February 22, 2010 to finalize regulations, and specified an effective date of August 22, 2010.

The Federal Register on April 1, 2010 (Happy Fool’s Day!) included the Fed’s final regulations, about a month late – except they weren’t really final because the Federal Register for this morning, August 17, 2010, amended those final regulations, all of these effective five days from now, on August 22, 2010. Let's be fair to the Fed. In the meantime, Congress had changed the rules for applying the August 22 effective date (in a statute the President signed on July 27).

Guess how many words are in the regulations?

11,684, ten times the number in the statute. That is, 3 pages in the Act, 21 pages in the regulations.

“What on earth took nearly 12 thousand words to say?” asks Virginia.

Let’s see:

-- About 6,250 words to define 4 types of gift cards and exclusions.
-- About 1,550 words to describe the required disclosures.
-- About 1,375 words to address the prohibition on fees.
-- About 1,680 words to explain a limited prohibition on expiration dates.
-- About 810 words to tell when the regulations take effect.

“I think I know where you’re headed,” Virginia reads my mind. “How many words are in the financial reform bill?”

“I’ve estimated 340,000,” I say.

“So you only have 3,400,000 words left to analyze, interpret and explain,” she says.

At least 6,110 pages. Sigh.

“Brighten up,” she says. “It’s lifetime employment.”

Hey, my life’s going to continue longer than that, if I have anything to say about it.

Sunday, July 25, 2010

Plain Vanilla

I normally prefer mint chocolate chip, but if I had to choose one flavor, I'd pick plain vanilla, to which I can always add chocolate, raspberries, chocolate chips, or whatever else my mood desires.

As I read articles by industry insiders, I'm struck by the generally negative attitude toward the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, as if it would be traitorous not to gripe.

If you think about it, you'll realize the bill is good for most of the commentators.  It basically offers lifetime security to compliance officers and banking lawyers.  They might as well gripe, if that endears them to the corporate teams who hire them.

Two provisions have wide support, even within in the business world.  Title I creates the Financial Stability Oversight Council to keep an eye on players whose activities "threaten the financial stability of the United States," a/k/a "systemic risk."  The Council's task is to identify risks like those created by subprime lending so it can head each risk off at the pass.

The other likable move is Title II, which sets up a liquidation process for firms that pose systemic risk and are on the verge of default.  The Federal government did not have a process like this handy the last time around, other than bankruptcy, which is chosen by a company or its creditors, not the government.  Now, the government can take over the firm and wind down its affairs, not perpetuate it by offering a bailout.  Once a firm enters the process, the only way out is its death.  The bill specifically prohibits the use of taxpayer funds, except for limited loans that can only be made if the firm's assets can and will repay them.  Shareholders and creditors are out of luck until the loans have been repaid.  They will get nothing unless money remains on the table after the firms assets have been liquidated.

These two provisions are easy to support because they don't affect "us."  They only bother the bad guys.

"But what about all the limitations, especially those on mortgages?" asks Virginia.  "Will we consumers be left with few choices, just 'plain vanilla' products?"

"Plain vanilla" seems to have gained currency as the favorite derogatory term to throw at Title XIV (mortgage reform).  Forget, shall we, that the most popular ice cream flavor remains "plain vanilla."  I seriously doubt that consumers are going to miss prepayment penalties, mandatory arbitration clauses or flimsy, virtually nonexistent underwriting standards.  Maybe lenders will, but prior to the 1990s, all of us lived without these features for many years.  Even back then, we had choices -- including adjustable rate and graduated payment mortgages.  Let me hedge the future.  I'm willing to bet that lenders will continue to offer many choices.